BeEzrat HaShem

Can A Jew Learn Torah From A Christian Or Messianic Jew? - MUSSAR Pirkei Avot (24)

9 years ago

Rabbi Yaron Reuven addresses the issue of inviting Christian and Messianic Jewish speakers to Jewish communities. He emphasizes the Torah prohibition against learning from heretical sources and the severe spiritual risks involved. Rabbi Reuven criticizes the decision of a synagogue to host a prominent Catholic missionary, highlighting the potential for leading Jews astray. He references halachic sources to support his stance, arguing that any association with idol worshippers, even for seemingly secular topics, is forbidden. The shiur stresses the importance of safeguarding Jewish faith and preventing chilul Hashem (desecration of God's name). Join this channel to get access to perks: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCi-fAdFBv83gUzBgKm3PAyw/join BUILD WITH US (Who Is BeEzrat HaShem Inc) http://www.BHYESHIVA.com BeEzrat HaShem YESHIVA & BEIT MUSSAR BUILDING BUILD A JEWISH COMMUNITY THAT WILL CHANGE THE WORLD 00:00 Introduction 01:01 Introduction 02:09 The disaster at Boca Raton Synagogue. Who is Matthew Kelly? 05:34 The zealousness of Pinchas. This is not a personal attack. People who are comfortably numb. 17:14 Chapter 2 Mishnah 12. The significance of Rabbi Eliezer ben Hurkenos 23:20 Teach the whole Torah, not just the part people like. Part 1 27:20 What can we learn from the story of Purim? Where was G-d during the holocaust? 30:24 Teach the whole Torah, not just the part people like. Part 2 41:48 What to know about competition in the Torah world 45:44 Listening to a baal teshuva. Be careful of missionaries like Matthew Kelly 56:11 Being enslaved by the evil inclination 1:00:25 The need to rebuke people. Does G-d really care about what I do? 1:10:18 How Eliezer ben Hurkenos rebuked and told the truth 1:12:42 Do not learn from a heretic including a missionary. Hear the sources for this 1:49:41 Chillul Hashem 2:01:16 Matthew Kelly is a missionary 2:14:19 Not even allowed to learn from a rabbi who has bad middot 2:17:17 Hear what Matthew Kelly said 2:28:59 Another issue at the Boca Raton Synagogue #MussarPirkeiAvot #Judaism #Jewish #RabbiYaronReuven #Torah #KIRUV #TeShuvah #matthewkelly #missionary #bocaraton 00:00:00 Intoduction 00:01:03 Introduction and Lecture Overview 00:01:47 Controversy: Catholic Missionary at Synagogue 00:03:29 Torah's Perspective on Idol Worship 00:04:55 Importance of Sourcing and Kavod Hashem 00:06:07 The Story of Bilaam and Pinchas 00:11:37 Kavod Hashem vs. Kavod HaRav 00:13:08 Stopping Chilul Hashem at All Costs 00:14:04 Loving Your Neighbor & Avoiding Sin 00:16:12 Personal Connection and Kavod Hashem 00:17:14 Mishnah and Competing Strategies in Kiruv 00:23:40 Critique of Modern Torah Teaching Methods 00:25:40 Gemara on Minim and Eternal Punishment 00:27:03 Purim Story & Consequences of Assimilation 00:29:55 Avoiding Missionary Lectures 00:30:25 Two Approaches to Torah Teaching 00:32:50 Desecration of Torah 00:34:35 Teshuva: Keeping Shabbat & Kosher 00:35:33 Consequences of a Flawed Torah 00:36:54 Teshuva Requires Hearing the Truth 00:40:31 Torah and Hardship 00:41:33 Competition and Envy in Torah 00:44:23 Mesilat Yesharim: Importance of Baal Teshuva 00:46:23 Alma DeSheikra and Lies of the World 00:48:18 Yetzer Hara and Satan's Strategies 00:50:43 Mesilat Yesharim on Foolishness and Evil Inclination 00:53:35 Church Spending 00:54:30 Matthew Kelly's Same Lectures 00:56:01 Being Blind 00:56:58 Isaiah 6:10 00:57:25 Avoiding the Naive 00:59:47 Advice: Find People 01:01:40 People's Struggles 01:03:06 The Satan's work 01:04:59 Loving Hashem 01:05:45 Listen to the Right One 01:07:06 Cheshbon (Accounting for your sins) 01:08:35 True Way 01:10:01 Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus 01:11:32 Digging your Grave 01:12:32 Minut(Heresy) 01:14:46 Wasting Talent 01:16:09 Appease Him 01:17:58 Finding Sin 01:18:56 Listening to a Heretic 01:20:23 Yaakov of Kfar 01:22:20 Kohen Gadol 01:23:51 Insult to the sinner 01:25:54 Distance Yourself 01:27:09 Avoid All Sin 01:28:36 Run Away 01:29:35 One Condition: Don't show a cross 01:31:05 Not even hang out 01:32:27 Love Your Neighbor? 01:33:48 Teenangers Connection to J.C. 01:35:46 His Blood Isn't Redder 01:37:02 One More Time 01:38:01 Not OKAY 01:41:41 Idol Worship 01:43:28 Burn It 01:45:14 Give A Compliment 01:46:35 Finalize This Part 01:47:35 I Called The Av Bait Din 01:49:23 You Be Worried 01:51:30 Pirkei Avot 01:53:18 Bacon 01:56:17 The Don't Return 01:57:50 My Wisdom 02:00:10 Look Into It 02:02:12 One Of the Top Missionaries 02:03:50 Catholics Don't Missionize 02:05:27 Oversight 02:07:17 Terrible News 02:08:44 Loss of a Jew 02:10:18 You Lost Everything 02:12:18 What to do? 02:13:36 Won't Be Canceling 02:15:02 You Made a Disaster 02:16:55 What God Do You Belive In? 02:19:17 Is That What They Mean By Righteous? 02:21:14 Anti-Semitism 02:23:27 I Want to be Liked 02:25:00 Second Vatican Council 02:27:01 Shift in Language 02:29:00 I'M VERY BUSY 02:31:38 Where Were You? 02:33:25 One Minute 02:34:23 Halacha 02:36:52 What's So Different About Me? 02:38:24 G-d Said So 02:40:16 What God Do You Believe In?

Transcript

1:03Hashem Hashem Na'aseh V'natzeach, Shiur Torah, great to be back, Baruch Hashem. And I've been touring at the Breslov Center. We've had continuous miracles. We had an amazing Brit Milah yesterday for my newborn son, Ovadia. Some of you came, Baruch Hashem, and many, many others. We had a nice shiur in it, which, B'ezrat Hashem, we will be publishing later today or tomorrow. And now we're back. We're back to work. We've always been working, but now we're back to doing some more lectures and continuing our very interesting, very lively Mussar series. Mussar series, I believe this is number 24. And we're going to continue with the Pirkei Avot, but there's going to be a few things added as usual to this shiur. Aside from learning the basic pshat, the basic translation or interpretation of Chazal of the Mishnah itself, we're also going to deal with

2:06The world today, the world at large, as many of you have seen, if you follow me on many groups that we have on WhatsApp, or Facebook, or Twitter, or our website, bezrat Hashem.org, you know, you've obviously seen this disaster that's happening at Boca Raton Synagogue right now, where a very big mistake is being made by the leaders to bring not only someone who's not exactly a Jewish leader, but the number one Catholic missionary in the world in disguise. In disguise. The interesting part about the disguise is that it's not much of a disguise. If you just type in his name, Matthew Kelly, and you go to dynamiccatholic.com, which is his company, or you go to his Wikipedia, or you go pretty much anywhere on Google, you'll immediately find his bio, what he says about himself, his book called I Know Jesus, which is one of many, many books that he sells for $2, and many other things that he recommends for the world at large to read and absorb and follow. And his whole life mission, despite making $30,000 to $40,000 a lecture, is to make everyone Catholic. Make everyone follow what the Torah says is 100% avodah zarah, 100% idol worship. The Torah calls such people in the Gemara, Masechet Rosh Hashanah, page 17, minim. Minim are people that are machti'ei rabim, that make other people sin, other people do something that's disgusting to Hashem.

3:29is to make everyone Catholic. Make everyone follow what the Torah says is 100% avodah zarah, 100% idol worship. The Torah calls such people in the Gemara, Masechet Rosh Hashanah, page 17, minim. Minim are people that are machti'ei rabim, that make other people sin, other people do something that's disgusting to Hashem. Even though there are many Christians that are even people that I'm friends with, there are many Christians that I care for. The fact that they are idol worshippers does not change just because I like them, just because you like them, just because they're charismatic, just because they may be very generous or very nice. It makes no difference. The Torah has a single truth. There are not two versions of the Torah. That's what the Christians say.

4:30which Christianity and Catholicism, in essence, are the same thing. They'll obviously tell you it's different, because one believes that Jesus is the Messiah but sometimes believes he's God. The other one believes he's three gods—it's God divided into three, Hashem. Plus, he has some saints that are helping him out in case he needs some help. I don't know what kind of God needs help, but their God needs help apparently. And you can pretty much do whatever you want, just as long as you confess to the priest; everything's okay. Which means that, as Matthew Kelly writes in his book, according to Jesus, Hitler is someone we should empathize with. And I'll bring you the sources, as we always try to provide sources. We brought sources, number one, because I know that no one should ever believe me; they should believe the source, whether it's a Torah source of Chazal, or it's anywhere else that we can find the actual sources. But aside from that, we need it. We need to know that everything that we're saying is not coming from my opinion. This is not a personal attack on Matthew Kelly. This is not a personal attack on the leaders at large of Boca Raton Synagogue.

5:45This is for the whole purpose of Kavod Hashem. This is only for Kavod Hashem. That's it. In Gemara Masechet Sanhedrin, page 82, we learn about what happened at the end of Parashat Balak and the beginning of Parashat Pinchas, when Bilaam cursed the nation, but it didn't work. He cursed Am Yisrael to try to kill them, but it didn't work even after Balak paid him a lot of money. So Bilaam said, "Listen, you don't really need my curse. I can't curse them anyway. As long as the God of Israel doesn't want them to get hurt, they're not going to get hurt." you could beat the system anyway. He's like, "How can I beat the system?" He said, "Send your girls. Send your girls with the mini skirts and tank tops. Send them to the camp of Israel. If they don't make sins with them, you win. Their own God will punish them." That's exactly what happened. Balak even sent his own daughter in a mini skirt and a tank top and tight clothes.

6:55Just like you see people going around and walking around and doing everything that they are doing, that's what they did. Back then, it was unknown to do such a thing. But that's what they did. In a matter of moments, Am Yisrael unfortunately started sinning. And the only time, according to Rav Pinchas, in his series of books, he says it's the only time in the entire Torah that Hashem Yitbarach punished us without a warning. Every single time Hashem punished us, He warned us first. Every single time. The only time in history He didn't warn us, not once, not twice, not even half a time, and immediately started punishing, is right after this. Right after we sinned with immodesty and when Zimri. sinned in public, the leader of the Shimon tribe, sinned in public by taking Kozbi, one of the non-Jewish women, which they say was the daughter of the king, and went in front of Moshe Rabbeinu and said, "Look, you converted your wife; I'll convert her too later. Let me do as I please for now. What makes your wife any better than mine?"

8:20I'm going to make her my wife now. He didn't want to go through a conversion process or a beit din or anything. And he went and started sinning with her in public. So Pinchas, the grandson of Aharon, the only one who did not receive the priesthood automatically like the rest of the sons of Aharon, came in front of Moshe Rabbeinu. And he said to him, Kavod HaRav, isn't there a halacha that you taught us that when someone is sinning in public like this, you can kill them? You're the one who taught us. And Moshe, according to Chazal, momentarily, because of the embarrassment and the shock of the sin and everything that was happening, he was crying with the rest of the elders and forgot, forgot this halacha momentarily. Hashem made him forget.

9:20because he saw the zealousness of Pinchas and he wanted to make sure that he earns what he deserves. He earns the mitzvah, he earns the eternal diamond, the priceless diamond that he wanted so much. And he gave him the opportunity by making Moshe forget. And Moshe said, yes, says, the one that remembers the halacha shall fulfill it. And Pinchas understood that and went about his way to go kill both Zimri and Kozbi, disregarding the fact that he was most likely going to be killed immediately because this wasn't exactly some old fool hiding under a bridge with a 40-ounce beer. This was like a president, president of a tribe. This is no less than a president of a country. And he went in the middle of his camp, inside his tent, took his spear and stabbed both of them while they were cohabiting, in the middle of the act.

10:47He got so scared because, obviously, the people came in right after that, his neshama came out of his body. And Chazal tells us that Hashem was so pleased with his zealousness that He put it back. And not only put it back, but He gave him extra strength. that gave him the ability to lift both of them, both bodies on the spear, while pushing everyone away. No one was able to touch him or harm him, and he showed this to everyone in the camps of Israel: This is what you do, this is what Hashem does, this is what you're supposed to do when there's Chilul Hashem. So the Gemara asks, in the same Masechet Sanhedrin, how is it, that Pinchas, as righteous as he is and as he gets a special bracha from Hashem Yitbarach at the beginning of Parashat Pinchas, how is it that he violated one of the major laws in the Torah, which is to say a halacha in front of his Rav? You don't have to say a halacha in front of your Rav. If your Rav is over there, you have to be quiet. Let him say the halacha. You can ask a question, even if you know it.

12:05How is it that Pinchas went about it and said, "Listen, I'm just going to go, without asking Moshe Rabbeinu if I should go kill him, I'm going to go kill him." Why didn't he ask his Rav? Why didn't he ask his Rav? He doesn't have any honor? Doesn't have any kavod? No. The Gemara says, in a place that there is There is no consideration whatsoever to the honor of the Rabbi. Because Kavod Hashem, the honor of Hashem, supersedes everyone. Supersedes you, supersedes your parents, supersedes your wife, supersedes your Rabbi, supersedes Moshe Rabbeinu. There is no consideration whatsoever to a Rabbi when there is Chilul Hashem.

13:08And this is one of the things that people need to understand if they're watching this right now or they're watching this later; this is by no means a personal battle. Although I spent many years, Baruch Hashem, on Wall Street doing research and I have enough research on every one of the parties involved to write a book, the point is we'll only disclose what's necessary, when necessary. Why? Because we need to stop this at all costs. We need to make sure the 1,000 families that live in Boca Raton that are what I call comfortably numb, comfortably numb, comfortably clueless, comfortably enjoying this world and having no consideration whatsoever that the Mashiach is around the corner. because they're in the process of building the next million-dollar house, buying the newest model of whatever car they want, and getting whatever honor they get at Beit Knesset, we're comfortably numb. We care less about loving your neighbor as yourself. You know, when we first made an announcement of this disaster that's happening, people say, no, you should

14:36Do this privately. I said, we did. We didn't just go public with the information. We have to follow Torah. This is not opinion. My opinion is meaningless. We did go private, which we'll go over momentarily. We went private for almost a week. We're running out of time. Yeah, but you shouldn't say such things. What am I saying? It's all true. They're saying it too. I'm just stating one extra fact they failed to mention. The same guy that's a speaker, he's a missionary. What's the problem? Oh, and it's not allowed to bring him to a shul. Just in case you guys forgot you were Jewish, you're not allowed to bring him to a shul. And we'll go over the halachot of why. Yeah, but what about loving your neighbor? whether he's Jewish or not Jewish, what about loving him? Okay, I can love him, but I don't have to bring him to the Beit Knesset. I don't have to bring him to the Beit Knesset, and I'm specifically not going to bring him to the Beit Knesset, because I love my neighbor. Because I know that his main agenda,

15:50is to collect my brothers and sisters. Now, since a large part of the kehillah is frum from birth, they're all born frum, with a hat already. At the Brit Milah, they all had a hat, and everyone had a kittel, and everyone is Jewish from birth, and everyone is wonderful. They have no idea, no idea what teshuvah is like. They have no idea what the overwhelming majority of Am Yisrael is like. Zero connection. How do I know? I was part of the kehillah for the last two and a half years. I live there. It's three minutes from my house. It's the shul I've been going to. This is not some outside perspective, and I just decided to ambush somebody because I'm jealous of whatever reason there is to be jealous of anyone in the world. I live there. I'm putting myself on the line more than anyone else. If anyone wants to go crazy, I'm right there with my family, with my two little kids, right there. But for the honor of Hashem, nothing matters. Nothing. Not the missionary, not the rabbis, not the shul, not the neighbors, not the terrorists, not ISIS, not anyone. That's Kavod Hashem.

17:14So now, in the Mishnah that we have today, it's Perek Bet, Yud Bet, and maybe we'll do also Yud Gimel. We'll connect it to the story that's happening. He was accustomed to say, "If all of the sages of Israel were on one pan of a balanced scale, and Eliezer ben Hyrcanus were on the other, he would outweigh them all." Abba Shaul said in the name of Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai, "If all of the sages of Israel, with even Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus among them..." He was accustomed to say, "If all of the sages of Israel were on one pan of a balanced scale, and Eliezer ben Hyrcanus were on the other, he would outweigh them all." Abba Shaul said in the name of Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai, "If all of the sages of Israel, with even Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus among them,

18:33on one pan of the balance scale and Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus was on the other, he would outweigh them all. So this is a very, very short and simple Mishnah. It actually has, in this book at least, the least amount of commentary from the sages out of all the Mishnayot. In essence, this is an all-time battle between the sages, a debate, if you will, to be someone like Rabbi Elazar ben Arach, who is called someone that is like a spring, flowing stronger and stronger, meaning continues to expand on the teachings of the sages, the commentary, and continues to expand and develop the Torah into to be like Rabbi Elazar ben Arach, who is called someone that is like a spring, flowing stronger and stronger, meaning continues to expand on the teachings of the sages, the commentary, and continues to expand and develop the Torah into. Not Chas V'Shalom that Rabbi Eliezer ben Hurkenus did not have chidushim, but they're saying that Rabbi Elazar ben Arach was greater, in that regard at least. In the sages' debate, in Gemara Masechet Horayot, Rabban Gamliel, Rabban Shimon ben Gamliel and the sages disagree on what kind of sage is superior. They call it a Sinai.

20:00Not, Chas V'Shalom, that Rabbi Eliezer ben Hurkenus did not have chidushim, but they're saying that Rabbi Elazar ben Arach was greater, in that regard at least. In the sages' debate, in Gemara Masechet Horayot, Rabban Gamliel, Rabban Shimon ben Gamliel, and the sages disagree on what kind of sage is superior. They call it a Sinai. which is someone that mastered all of the subjects of the Torah, or an Oker Harim, which is an uprooter of mountains, which is what they're saying, Rabbi Elazar ben Arach was. So in today's world, there's really no possibility for us to understand the significance of Rabbi Eliezer ben Hurkenus. And the reason why is because none of us could actually even understand the student of his student. Who is the student of his student? If you all remember, his student was Rabbi Akiva, whom the holy books say was the only person to ever reach the highest level of kedusha. Even higher than Moshe Rabbeinu. Moshe Rabbeinu reached 49, Rabbi Akiva reached 50. He started as a baal teshuva at age 40,

21:25divorced with a kid and illiterate. Over the next 80 years, he became the holiest man that ever lived. That's the student of Rabbi Eliezer ben Hurkanos. His student, Rabbi Akiva, one of his many, many students, had over 24,000 students who died, and then he restarted everything with five new ones. One of those five is Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai. Rabbi Shimon Bar Yochai, as I'm sure all of you have heard the name, he's the one that put together the Zohar. But also, one of the other interesting things they write about Rabbi Shimon Bar Yochai is that he was able to either kill someone or bring someone back to life with just three words. That's it. Four words, he actually said one time: "the living will die, the dead will come back to life." When a bunch of hoodlums tried to go against him, hurt Am Yisrael, he said, "Oh, you'll switch. You're going to die, and the ones you killed are going to live." That's exactly what happened. Four words. Four words, a bunch of people died who were wicked, and a bunch of people who were righteous came back to life.

22:41That's the student of the student of Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus. We can't understand that. The most we can say is maybe we can say Rabbi Shimon. To understand the concept of bringing back the dead. Who else did they say could bring back the dead? Hashem. This is one of His sages. He gave him the power to do such a thing. How can we... Today's world, no one can understand such a thing. So, of course, we can't understand Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus. But what we can understand is the competing strategies of doing Kiruv, competing strategies of teaching Torah. There's an unfortunate debate about the topic ...where unlike the past, where everyone knew there are many shittot, there are many strategies to bring people back to Hashem, there are many shittot to get people closer to Hashem, there are many different ways to teach Torah. In today's world, some decided that they're going to force the world to teach Torah in one certain way, the yeshivish way...

24:11and if you don't teach Torah that way, you're banned. And this is why just recently they came out with a horrendous letter of 16 rabbis who decided to sign a letter saying that no one should listen to Rabbi Mizrachi, the number one kiruv rabbi of our generation. No one should listen to him all of a sudden. So all of these families that have done teshuva, have their kids go to yeshiva, have converted, have changed their lives, my own included, we shouldn't listen to them anymore. Why? Because he says the entire Torah, not just the half that's really nice. The half that's really nice, you know, Avraham Avinu, Yaakov Avinu, the nice stories, yeah, that's nice. But, you know, no, that's quiet.

25:12Parashat Ki Tavo, no, no, no, we don't, we don't, we do it quietly in Beit Knesset so no one can actually hear it. We don't want to talk about curses. We only want to talk about how Hashem loves us. Okay, yes, Hashem loves us. That's why we're still alive. But if you actually listen to half the Torah, He also says that He punishes us. And if anyone wants to look at some Gemara, Gemara, Masechet Rosh Hashanah, the same place that talks about Minim. Same place, page 17, it says that some people, that are Minim specifically, get a very interesting punishment. The punishment is eternal, forever. They go to Gehenom, and it says specifically in the Gemara, that even when the Mashiach And even when the world ends, this natural world ends, their Gehenom, the fire in their Gehenom will not end. It won't end. This is pshat. This is basic. This is not like some commentary of commentary of commentary. This is basic level understanding. Much, much hotter Gehenom,

26:35then it's hot today here. And how they shut off the air conditioner for me. It's your weekly duty. So I'm just trying to remind you in a nice way. Much hotter. But nonetheless, yes, Hashem loves us. But He also brought the Holocaust. And He also punishes many of us. And He also brought the pogroms and the Spanish Inquisitions. And what happened during Purim and Chanukah and the First Beit Hamikdash and the Second Beit Hamikdash. It all happened. It really didn’t even have pictures. As a matter of fact, there’s a holiday that’s coming up soon. All Jews like this holiday, especially the non-religious ones. It’s called Purim. Purim. But what's the story of Purim? The story of Purim in five words is simply: the Rabbis decided to make peace. So they went and celebrated with the goyim. They had a couple of drinks. They didn't go listen to a missionary, chas v'shalom.

27:57Come on, even back then, they knew not to listen to missionaries. But they went and had a couple of drinks with the goyim. The king had a party celebrating that the Beit HaMikdash had not been rebuilt. He invited everyone to come. There were six months' worth of parties. "Come for one night," he said. "You don't have to come for six months, come for one night. I'll even have kosher wine, Manischewitz. Come, you'll have your own kosher department." They have a Winn-Dixie, you know, your kosher department for your rabbis. So, we went, even though one of the gedolim said don't go. We didn't listen to him. What does he know? He was only number four, and the Sanhedrin wasn't number one. Come on, I'm not gonna listen to number one. I got a talk from Mordechai, who was number four. I didn't hear from number one, two, or three; they didn't say anything, they were busy. number four said don't go. Numbers five, six, seven, eight, nine, and ten — maybe they said yes, so that's better than number four. So we had a couple of drinks with the goyim. And as we all know what happens next: Hashem decides to bring the Holocaust. But much worse than the Holocaust, He brings a person by the name of Haman, yimach shemo vezichro, who was much, much worse than Hitler. And the reason why is because Hitler

29:24His plan and his strategy was to torture us and kill us over an extended period of time. Haman wanted to kill all of us in a single day. And he almost succeeded. For what? Not for listening to a missionary. Not for attending a missionary lecture. Not even for idol worshipping. For having a couple of drinks with people we were not supposed to have drinks with. Kal vachomer. Needless to say, what do you think Hashem's opinion is about listening to a missionary? And then people ask, oh, where was God during the Holocaust? We had a whole lecture about it. As a matter of fact, three of them. The simple answer we begin the lecture with is, He was there. He did it. Stop going to missionary lectures. That's a big, big choice.

30:25So Rabbi Eliezer ben Hurkanus was Kodesh Kodashim, remembered every halacha, every mishnah, everything you could possibly imagine as we've talked about in the past. Something beyond our understanding. Rabbi Eliezer ben Arach expanded and developed and used own experience to explain to us how and what to do and what the purpose of life is. Even though he made a mistake at some point in his life, and the Mishnah actually mentions it, he ended up losing all of his Torah until all of the sages prayed for him to get it back. Nonetheless, these are two different mindsets in today's world. The so-called Rabbanim that decided to go against the real way of teaching Torah, which is the full Torah, including the punishments, including the not-so-pleasing things to hear, including the politically incorrect stuff. They said, no, no, it's not good. It's too much for us. It's too much for our generation. People can't handle that. Who are you?

31:53to tell me what I can handle. Who are you to decide for Am Yisrael what they can handle? Why, because you were born with a hat and a beard? Because the only wardrobe you have is black and white? Because you know a few Mishnayot by heart? Or because you got a semicha? Because you went to school for two and a half years? Or four years? Or five years? Or you became a Dayan? Where is your Yirat Shamayim? How about that? Because according to the very same Gemara that you learned, I also learned. And according to that Gemara, it says that someone who is considered a Talmid Chacham, but has bad middot, bad character traits, Neveila serucha tova mimenu—a dead animal on the street is better than him. The Gemara said it, not me. So, who are you to change Hashem's Torah and tell Am Yisrael what they can handle? What, so they can't handle Rabbi Mizrahi, but they can handle a missionary? Because he's inspiring? Because he wrote 100 books or 20 books? Because, according to his Wikipedia profile, he sold more books about Catholicism and Jesus than the New Testament?

33:18They said he's number two, New Testament one, Matthew Kelly number two. So that's better than bringing Rabbi Mizrahi. It's better than bringing a Baal Teshuva that has an inspiring story. It's better that Am Yisrael can handle that. So the thought process is, So you're not allowed to teach Torah as it's always been taught for 3,300 years. It's supposed to be taught in a different way, and this is a desecration of the Torah. Because even though we sat quietly for a long time, Trust me, for me, somebody like me that has a gift of gab, sitting quiet for two and a half years is a long time for me. I think I went to, you know, I told you about the seven years of Gehenom, of physical, with the health situations, this was like two and a half years of spiritual Gehenom for me. Being quiet. Seeing a kehillah, I bring people to do teshuva, they start going to beit knesset.

34:35What do they do? They go to the kehillah. Oh, no, everything's okay. You're a tzaddik, you're a tzaddik, you're a tzaddik. They start driving on Shabbat again. I beg people to do teshuva. Finally, they start keeping Shabbat, keeping kosher, keeping taharah, keeping tzniut, keeping something. They go to beit knesset. No, no, you don't have to listen to Yaron. He doesn't have semicha. He didn't go to Yeshiva University with me. He wasn't part of the honor roll. He wasn't part of the system. But does he say anything wrong about Torah? Maybe his opinion is not like your opinion. Maybe his life is not like your life. But is anything that I say regarding Torah wrong? They haven't found that yet. But he shouldn't listen to me. So I said, okay, so I'm not going to listen to him. And what happens? They stop going to lectures. They stop listening. They start listening to them. About halachot for etrogim. And halachot for the Beit HaMikdash that we don't have right now, unfortunately. And little by little, they get weaker and weaker and weaker, and that's it. And this has happened several times. It's enough of being quiet.

35:56The reality of it is that there are multiple ways of bringing back people to Hashem. Yes, the yeshivish way does work for some people. Yes, telling people God is wonderful and loves you all the time does work for some people. Some. But on the grand scope of things, if you look at statistics, if you look at real-life experience, you ask everyone around you that's a Baal Teshuva, What and who made you do teshuva? The overwhelming majority of people must have had either Hashem beat them up or a Rabbi's words beat them up. Someone had to beat them up. Something had to happen. People do not change their life because they like a story. Yes, Rabbi Akiva is wonderful. Moshe Rabbeinu, amazing. I'm not going to change my life because of them. because I don't respect them yet until I start keeping what they taught. I can't connect to Moshe Rabbeinu. His face lit up like the sun. I don't even understand what that means. I'm not gonna tell my wife that I can't be with her for half the month because his face lit up for half the month, for the whole time he was going down from the mountain. Doesn't make sense to me. Why would my wife be separated from me because of that? Why would I dress a certain way

37:25Because Rabbi Akiva did teshuva at age 40, that's his problem. That's the secular mentality. He wants to do teshuva, let him do teshuva. What do I have to do teshuva for? Why would I do teshuva if you tell me on your fancy podium that there are five different opinions about a single halacha? To me, all that means is that everyone doesn't know what they're talking about. someone's lying, someone's foolish, someone doesn't have an idea of what's going on, and one of the guys may be right. As a secular person, that's what I used to think. Obviously, today I understand why. But as a secular mentality, which is the overwhelming majority of Am Yisrael, someone enabled of 70 to 80 percent do not even keep Shabbat. We call that secular, and Telling them there are five different opinions on a single halacha is not making them closer to Yiddishkeit. I'm sorry. If anything, it's distancing them. To a secular person, five different opinions, three different opinions, two different opinions. To me, that means there are two different Torahs. It doesn't mean that both of them are right somehow.

38:45It doesn't mean that Shmaya and Avtalyon were such amazing people that they were able to keep it together. But then when they got to Beit Shammai and Beit Hillel, their students weren't able to. They had constant conflict, but for Shamayim, not for personality and ego. It doesn't make any sense to me as a secular person. So I'm sorry if my yelling and screaming is disturbing you. And I'm sorry if my hardship is not as heartwarming to you as you'd like for it to be. But the sad reality of it is that people do teshuva when they hear the truth. When you start telling people that Hashem loves you regardless of what you do, and yes, He punished Am Yisrael for immodesty back then, but today you're allowed to walk around with a miniskirt and a tank top. because we're a weak generation. To me, my friend, as someone that has an IQ slightly above a monkey, I know that's not realistic. It doesn't sound realistic, this Torah of yours that's all wonderful. Because life is not all wonderful. Life has hardship. Life has sickness and disease.

40:04Life has death. Like one of my students, her daughter died suddenly; she got sick one day, and two days later, the child died at seven years old. I try to comfort her as often as I possibly can. What do you tell someone whose child died at seven years old? What do you tell them? God loves you? What do you tell them? What are you going to tell them? I have another student, who just told me two days ago that his son has cancer. He's 12 years old. His Bar Mitzvah comes up in March. What are you going to tell him? What do you think of my beard? Or did you see my video on YouTube? Or just make sure you give some tzedakah to the shul. What are you gonna tell him? Life is hard. Life has difficulties. Life has hardships. Life has cancer. A Torah that doesn’t have punishment is not a real Torah. No one does teshuva for something fake.

41:33No one. And anyone that ever did teshuva because of this nonsense, it's not because of the nonsense, it's just they wanted to do teshuva; they just used it as an excuse, a crutch. So the thought process in this Mishnah is that they're having a competition. They're saying on one side, Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus is the greatest. On the other hand, there's another side that says that Rabbi Elazar ben Arach is better. What, they need to have a competition? What is this, American Idol? With a TV show, whoever wins gets a million dollars? First and foremost, it's teaching us that competition is good. It's healthy. There are different character traits that one must have in order to succeed. But of course, it all has to be controlled. Being envious in the regular secular world is a horrible, horrible disease because that means that you will never, ever be happy with what you have. You're constantly counting everyone else's money.

43:00I would have people come to me when I was on Wall Street and constantly ask me how much money I made today, like it made a difference to them. Or they would tell me about some baseball player or some celebrity that just signed a contract for a gazillion dollars. And I asked them, is he gonna pay the $150,000 a month in bills I have? They said, no. So I said, I'm not interested then. What do I care how much money he has? Why do you care how much money I have? Envy is a disease. But envy in the Torah world is necessary. If you want to succeed in Torah, then you have to be jealous of a Talmid Chacham. Because that's the only thing that's going to drive you to study at 1:30 and 2 o'clock in the morning instead of going to sleep like a little baby for eight hours. Envy is the only thing that's going to get you To open a Chumash, a Gemara, a Mishnah, or any Sefer Kodesh instead of watching some stupid Super Bowl, even if the Super Bowl party is in the shul. You're envious of Rav Ovadia Yosef.

44:23You're envious of Rav Moshe Feinstein, you're envious of all of the Gedolei HaDor, you're envious of Moshe Rabbeinu. You're envious. Who doesn't want to be Moshe Rabbeinu? Who doesn't want to be Moshe Rabbeinu? Every Baal Teshuva in history probably wanted to be Moshe Rabbeinu at one point. Some of us probably thought we were, as soon as we started laying tefillin. You read some Tehillim, you're like, ha, he and Moshe Rabbeinu are like this. Everyone thinks they're holier than what they really are. So first and foremost, it says, competition is good if it's for Shamayim. You can't tell me my shitta doesn't work when I have a Baal Teshuva or a convert every single day. It has nothing to do with me. I just did Teshuva.

45:23I haven't studied anywhere near as many years as all of these rabbis. Some of them were born with a hat and a beard already. They went to school, they went to yeshiva, they were fortunate enough to be in yeshiva their whole life. I'm jealous of them. But why does the Mesilat Yesharim say that if you want to do Teshuva, or you want to get closer to Hashem, you're more likely to succeed by listening to a Baal Teshuva? This is not me, it's the Ramchal. Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzatto, a few hundred years ago, wrote a book, what many believe was through Ruach HaKodesh. Why does the Mesilat Yesharim say that if you want to do Teshuva, or you want to get closer to Hashem, you're more likely to succeed by listening to a Baal Teshuva? This is not me, it's the Ramchal. Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzatto, a few hundred years ago, wrote a book, what many believe was through Ruach HaKodesh. In the third chapter, he says this. In the material and corporeal world, the material and corporeal world operate in this way. It is the darkness of the night to the eye of the intellect and causes two errors. It prevents the individual from seeing the obstacle standing in the pathway of this world.

46:52so that the fools walk confidently, stumbling and perishing without prior awareness of fear, as the verse in Mishlei (Proverbs) chapter 4, verse 19 says: "The path of the wicked is like darkness; they know not what they stumble." So first, he says this world is obviously the Alma DeSheikra, a world full of lies. And there are many, many people who are just clueless about what the purpose of life is. Interestingly enough, those very same fools who have no idea of what's going on, of what reality is, why you're in this world, and the fact that you didn't come from a monkey. Or, if you think you came from a monkey, you probably did come from a monkey, but I didn't come from a monkey. You actually may even be a monkey. But the fools of the world... They always end up walking confidently, chest stuck up, thinking they're tzaddikim. Not even knowing that each and every single step they take is destroying their olam haba. As we learn in the Mishnah in Avot, someone that's clueless will never have any yirat shamayim. Why? Because he doesn't even know what to be afraid of.

48:18in order to be afraid of it. It also says in Proverbs 14:16, "The fool is filled with transgressions and feels secure." He makes sins nonstop, but he feels great. He has no idea they're even sins. The second error is even greater than the first. So it's not about the fools who have no idea of what's going on. He says this is a second type of people. is that the darkness distorts their perception to the degree that they see evil as if it were beneficial and good, and good as if it were harmful. As a result, they strengthen themselves and reinforce their evil deeds. The second confusing thing that the Satan does to us, the Yetzer Hara, the Satan, and the Malach HaMavet, it's all the same thing according to the Torah. The Gemara says he actually has seven other names, and Moshe Rabbeinu called him Ra. And he sent us a train. It usually comes at 12:30. Today it came early, as soon as we said his name. Rabbi Mizrachi gets a fly, I get a train. I got a fly once, yeah, I got a fly once. I'll get many flies. So,

49:45He says the second strategy of the Satan is he fools you to such an extent that he makes you think that you're doing a mitzvah. But in reality, everything you're doing, you're thinking you're helping the community; you're bringing a speaker to talk to them about the purpose of life. Okay, but he's a missionary, he's a Catholic, he's trying to convert the whole congregation in secret. but he's very nice and charismatic. You can see his YouTube videos. If I didn't know it was idol worship, I'd do it too. But he's helping the community. What is he helping them with? Build a nice beit knesset, a villa, a VIP one? What's he helping them with? No, but we'll change the topic. So what they do, not only did they make it free, instead of hiding this event, after finding out that this guy's an idol worshiper, a missionary, instead of hiding the event, they publicized it even more. They said, now it's easier for you to come. We'll make it free. Instead of charging you $36 to come, we'll make it free. And we'll change the topic though. Why do you change the topic if everything was fine? Why did you change the topic from the purpose of life

51:12which, in small parentheses in Matthew Kelly's head, is according to Jesus, to work and life balance. If everything was so wonderful, why did you say tzadik? Because the Satan tells you that what you're doing is a mitzvah, you're helping the community. It's not you that I hate, it's the sin. So the Mesilat Yesharim, which convinces all types of people, whether rabbis or boors, to make bad decisions, also says not only do they lack the ability to see the truth and perceive the evil that is before them, they also think that they can find analytical proof and concrete evidence to draw from life to support their evil ideas and their deceitful opinions. Satan is so smart, he makes you think it's a mitzvah. Not only a nice thing to do, but a mitzvah. So what do they say? Listen, if we cancel

52:33No, because the nations will hate the Jews if we cancel this lecture. But if it was someone that you just found out is a mass murderer in disguise, and he supports the Palestinians for a single-state solution only being a Palestinian state, not a Jewish one, you'd cancel it immediately. You wouldn't ask two questions. You would say, no, no, maybe they're going to hate us. Maybe two billion people are going to hate us. The fact that two billion Arabs hate you, you don’t care about. If it was a Zionistic issue, no, we're going to cancel it. He believes in terrorism. We're not going to have him at our shul. But when it comes to Kavod Hashem, no, it's not convenient. It's not nice. It's not polite.

53:35Maybe he's just not really looking to convert us because, you know, the Catholics are not missionaries. Who told you that? Ask the Catholic. Ask him. Ask him, what is your purpose in life? Why do they have a video by Matthew Kelly to train missionaries? Who are you missionizing? Why does the Catholic Church spend 300 million dollars a year in Israel to convert Israelis? 300 million dollars to you rich Americans doesn't sound like much money. Because in America, a little homeless neighborhood has a 300 million dollar budget somehow. No one has a house or food to eat, but there's 300 million dollars going to the budget for the government officials. Israel, 300 million dollars is a significant percentage of the GDP of the overall economy. They spend 300 million dollars a year just hunting Jews to get them to worship their idol worship. And we're not gonna do that because we're gonna take a day off. Matthew Kelly's gonna take a day off. She'll talk to us about time management.

55:02Even his own people, you look us up on the internet, very easy to find, complain about him. He was invited for the very same lecture he's about to do, chas v'shalom, the very same lecture, time management, purpose of life, all this hogwash political lingo. Same lecture, he did it at a university. And the students wrote a whole blog and report. This guy is full of it. This whole event was a missionary event. He started putting missionary music on, and missionaries went to work. He started talking to us about JC Penney and this one and that one, and everybody has to be Christian, and the purpose of life is to be. This is not the first time. There's a whole multi-million dollar company about this. What, he's gonna take a day off for BRS? that's the least of our problems. We should pay him another 40,000 just not to come. Do ourselves a favor. So, in case we are not wicked and it's just our evil inclination, it's just we're clueless because we're born with a hat and a beard and secluded from the rest of the world, and

56:27and we have no idea how real life is. And we really do believe that everything is wonderful, and there's no disease or hardship or trouble. Then the Mesillat Yesharim says, however, those who have left this prison know the truth. Going back a few lines, The heart of this people has become fleshy, and their ears heavy, and their eyes covered shut. Lest they see with their eyes, and with their ears hear, their heart will understand. This is all from Isaiah 6:10. It's a verse describing these people that are, in essence, being fooled by the Yetzer Hara. And then the Mesillat Yesharim says, and all of this is because they live in darkness and are enslaved by their evil inclination. he's saying let's say they're not wicked, they're just fooled. They're fooled because they didn't see the real world. They don't actually realize that eighty percent of Am Yisrael does not keep Shabbat or the ones that don't keep taharat hamishpacha because they don't feel like it, not because they have no idea that it's the worst possible sin in Judaism. They have no clue and no one wants to tell them because if you tell them, that's not an approved strategy.

57:50you tell people that wasting seed is killing 300 million souls each time you do it. That's not an approved strategy in yeshiva. Now they don't teach that anymore. If you tell people that, according to the Rambam, chapter 30, it is considered 100% idol worship, it's not an approved strategy. You shouldn't do it. If you tell somebody that Chazal say that if you actually kill a Mechalel Shabbat with Sekilah in the days of the Sanhedrin, you're doing him a favor, because at least he won't violate Shabbat anymore. It's not an approved strategy. It's not nice. So let's just say for now, we're all naive. We're all born in a box. A black and white box. and we have no idea that the world at large is secular. The world at large is full of idol worship. The world at large is anti-Semitic. The world at large is waiting for another Holocaust. Even our allies report that over 40% of America is officially anti-Semitic. Even Gorbachev came out of his hole recently saying the world is preparing a big war, wrote a whole big article about it.

59:17Why he came out of this hole, I don't know, but apparently Hashem thought it's a good idea to bring Gorbachev back and let us know what we should already know from the Torah. The world at large is preparing for an ultimate war. So in case we're naive and clueless, the Mesillat Yesharim is telling us that they live in darkness and are enslaved by their evil inclinations. Who should we look for? How do we do teshuva? How do we get back to Hashem? Those who have already left this prison, already have overcome the yetzer hara, already have seen the tum'ah and fakeness of this world, whether it be on Wall Street or some other nonsense of this material world, and they've overcome this prison you call world. They've overcome the lies. They know the truth of these matters completely. They are capable of advising others. And he continues, if someone was in a garden, shaped like a maze,

1:00:44that was planted for amusement and is familiar to the noblemen. In this kind of garden, the hedges are arranged like walls and among them are numerous paths, confusing and interconnected, one the same as the next. Everything looks the same; everyone knows what a maze looks like. The goal of someone walking through this maze, which obviously is a parable or an analogy for life, The goal of someone walking through this maze is to reach the gazebo in the center of the garden, to reach the purpose of life. One who walks along these paths is not capable of seeing or knowing at all if he's taking the right route or a mistaken one. One who's just going through the paths, walking through life, has no idea if he's going the right way or not. He's never been there before. He was just born, like my son Ovadia. He doesn't know anything. What does he know? All the Torah, there's no chance he remembers it, but most likely, not. So he's going to go through life, and unless he's given direct instructions, he's not going to know what to do. Everything looks the same to the observer. For someone experiencing this for the first time, everything looks the same.

1:02:07Going to the mall on Shabbat, going to the Beit Knesset on Shabbat. Why does God care about this or that? Okay, I believe in God, but why does God care if I go to the mall? Why does God care if I wear a tank top? God, I mean, with all the problems He has, He cares about whether I wear a tank top or not? He cares about whether I, you know, dress modestly or not? Really? That's His whole problem, me, little, little me? He cares about whether I do Netilat Yadayim or I do a bracha before I eat? He has the whole world to run, 7.5 billion people. He has terrorism, anti-Semitism. He has the government of Israel balagan going on a daily basis. That's enough to deal with. You have terrorists inside the government. He cares about whether I do Netilat Yadayim? He cares about whether I do Mincha at exactly 5:26 or 5:27? Or if I pray netz, he really cares, everything looks the same to me. If he doesn't care about this, then he probably doesn't care about that. That's how the Satan works in your mind. If he doesn't care whether I pray at 5:26 or at 6:26, then I'm not going to pray until 9. And if he doesn't really care that I prayed at 9, you know what, I'll just do tefillin right before mincha, so I can do both at the same time, bang it out. Finish it up. I'm being efficient.

1:03:36being efficient, time efficient. I'm doing everything; if I could do that also, that's what the Satan tells you. He says, "Come on tzaddik, you were up all the way till 1:30 in the morning, two o'clock in the morning last night. Hashem can't expect you to wake up for Netz. He doesn't really care that much about Netz. That's only the rabbi." There aren't several pages in the Gemara HaMasechet Brachot about it. No, no. That's just, some people wrote it. There isn't. They don't care. He doesn't care if you say thank you that you ate. He knows what you mean. He knows your heart. It's one of the 13 principles of faith. He knows your heart. He knows what you feel. So you say thank you inside. Like, thanks Hashem. I got you. Got you. Appreciate the bread. Thanks for the donut. knows. He knows what's in your heart. The Satan tells you everything looks the same and, sure, slowly but surely, we leave everything. We become completely secular, but we keep the kippah on. And that's why I sometimes have people who look 100% frum. I'm talking about the whole uniform. They don't even believe in God.

1:04:59They're so far away from the truth, they don't even believe in God. Obviously, this is not a small minority, but nonetheless, this happens. And then I have some people that have no idea why they're even in this world, but they love Hashem. more than many religious people that I know. They just don't have an idea of what He wants from them because they've never read the Torah. They're too busy being construction workers or mailmen or whatever they are in life. Too busy with the struggles of life. To them, everything looks the same. So the Mesilat Yesharim continues. It says, unless by prior experience and a keen eye, having been there once before, There is no way for him to know the route. Now, one who stands at the gazebo sees all the paths before him and discerns the correct ones from the false ones and is capable of forewarning those who are walking through them: "Take this route, take that one." Any person willing to place his trust in this individual will reach the designated place.

1:06:14One who is not willing to do this and follows his own eyes instead will surely remain lost and fail to reach it. The Mesilat Yesharim is telling you that someone who already did teshuva, went through Alma DeShikra, went through the lying world, knows what that other world looks like, overcame his yetzer hara, He's at the gazebo, not that he's Mashiach, not that he's even special. All he has is life experience. He knows a few things of Torah, he knows what the truth is, and he went through hardship. Needless to say, he has 23 years experience doing, helping people do teshuva, or a few years, or whatever it is. He's done it. Mesilat Yesharim is saying, That's who you have to listen to. And he finishes this chapter by saying, those who rule over their evil inclination, who have already reached the gazebo and have already left the path, and have clearly seen all the routes before them, they are competent to advise whoever is willing to listen. We must place our trust in them.

1:07:35anyone that wants to check the words after the lectures, don't think I'm making all this up. You can see it's highlighted to make it easy. And what is the advice they give us? What kind of key rule do they provide? Are they telling us about all the halakhot of the Bet Knesset to help us reach the gazebo? Are they telling us about how nice life is and that there is no struggle, just as long as you pray to some tzaddik? Are they telling us that as long as we donate to the Bet Knesset or to whatever cause they have today, and whatever pillar of society we have today, we're going to be fine? Is that what he's saying? No. What's the key strategy that the Mesilat Yesharim is saying? And what advice do they give us? "Bo'u le'Cheshbon." Cheshbon means come and do an accounting, an accounting for your sins. Come and evaluate the balance sheet of the world, meaning your own world. Calculate where your sins are versus the few mitzvot that you do. Where do you stand in God's balance sheet? For they have already experienced, seen, and learned that this alone, according to him, is the only strategy.

1:09:01This alone is the true way for man to obtain the goodness that he seeks and none other. There is no other way according to the Ramchal. So the benefit of the doubt that I gave earlier today, that maybe some other shita works, according to the Ramchal, it doesn't work. Unless you're rebuking people and letting them know, "Hey, my friend, this is not allowed. You can do what you want, but it's not allowed." You can drive on Shabbat. I'm not your God. I can't kill you, nor do I want to. But it's not allowed. It's not allowed. It's not allowed to listen to a missionary. It's not allowed to drive on Shabbat. It's not allowed to eat non-kosher, regardless of where you are, whether it's at home, in private, or outside in public, at Starbucks. It's not allowed. You can do what you want, but it's not allowed. All I do is be the mailman. I tell you the news. This is what God said, not me. Do what you want. Consequences? We talk about those too. So the mindset that we need to remember everything by heart is good. But that really wasn't, because if you read

1:10:32Some of the things that Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus has said, he wasn't today's typical simple 18- or 20-year-old rabbi with a semicha who knows a few halachot by heart and can give you a d'var Torah for three minutes. When he saw that there was a drought implemented 13 fast days. Told the kehilah we have to fast 13 times. And when he saw that rain didn't start again, and all of the people left the beit knesset happy with themselves about how they prayed, he knew that nothing had changed in shamayim, meaning the prayer had not been accepted yet. He told his kehillah, "Have you all finished digging your graves? Because we're all going to die." They knew he wasn't some 18- or 20-year-old rabbi with semicha. They knew what he meant was real. So they all started crying hysterically and ran back into shul and started really praying, and it instantly started raining. He said, "Oh!"

1:12:01That was a real tefillah. If you read Tana Devei Eliyahu, some of the harshest, most difficult things to hear, including details about Gehenom, are in there. That's the book. The details, some of the things that Rabbi Eliezer Ben-Horkenos said. He wasn't your typical good memory rabbi. He rebuked, he told the truth, and the only thing that mattered to him in the world is Kvod Hashem. But this very same Rabbi Eliezer ben Horkenos, according to the Gemara, Masechet Avodah Zarah, page 16b, it says something very scary.

1:13:04The Rabbi is taught in the Beraita when Rabbi Eliezer was seized for heresy, for minut. They brought him up to the tiered court building to be judged, and a Roman official in charge said to him accusingly, A wise man such as yourself should engage in these idol matters? Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus said to him in reply, "The judge is trusted by me." So the Goyim saw Rabbi Eliezer, and they accused him of going against them. Him teaching Torah, him going against idol worship, was not pleasing to their agenda. So they accused him of some false charge, planning to kill him. And one of the main people, main officials, main Roman officials, came to him and said, "Somebody as smart as you, what are you studying this Torah for? What are you teaching this Torah for? Come, learn idol worship with us about JC Penny. Come, enjoy with us life, material, sports. What are you wasting your talent?"

1:14:20came to him and said, "Somebody as smart as you, what are you studying this Torah for? What are you teaching this Torah for? Come, learn idol worship with us about JC Penny. Come, enjoy life with us, materialism, sports. Why are you wasting your talent?" you're wasting your talent on this Torah stuff, this ancient stuff. Why? And Rabbi Eliezer said to him, the Judge is trusted by me. Meaning, the Judge, Hashem Yitbarach, I trust what He says. If He says I deserve punishment, I deserve punishment. Meaning, if you're going to kill me, That's what he wants. It has nothing to do with you. You're just a vessel. You're just a delivery man. Just a tool. I made some type of sin, and Hashem is punishing me. But this idiot Roman thought that he was talking about him. He thought he was calling him a judge, that he trusts whatever he wants for him. So, he thought he was speaking of him.

1:15:41And he said, "I have control over the judges, and I promise you, you're going to be released." So, in essence, it saved his life. If it were you or me, we'd be throwing a party. Yesterday, I was going to get the death penalty; right now, I'm free, and the guy likes me. A miracle. Rabbi Eliezer starts mourning. All of his students come to him, trying to appease him. He refuses to accept any of their advice, appeasements, and pleas of any kind. No consolation could do anything for him. Until Rabbi Akiva, a student, came to him and says, "My teacher, permit me to say one thing." From what you've taught me, meaning I'm not really saying my own thought, I'm reminding you of what you already know. Which is the very same way that the Mesilat Yesharim started the book. He's not here to tell us anything new, even though the whole thing is new. He's not here to tell us anything new. He's here to remind us of what we already know. So Rabbi Akiva, in his humility, says to Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus, my teacher, I'm just going to remind you of what you already know.

1:17:07he says, "Okay, try and speak, my teacher. Perhaps some teacher of heresy came to your hand and was repeated by you, perhaps, and it pleased you. And on that account, you were seized and nearly coerced into worshipping idols." All Rabbi Eliezer ben Hurkanos cares about right now is not the fact that his life was saved. He's looking for a sin that he made, and he can't find it. Look for a sin; you're going to find it instantly. If they actually write all the sins we make in one day, at least on my end, in one day, I don't think they're going to have enough parchment to write a new Torah. He's looking for the sin he made. He can't find it. Why would God want me, with all the Torah that I teach, with all the Torah that I learn, with all the students that I have, where Rabbi Akiva is one of them? One of my students has 24,000 students, where the least of them can revive the dead. Why would God want to put me in a situation where I'm this close to worshipping idols?

1:18:29That's all they wanted me to do. These Romans, they wanted to either kill me or make me worship one of their idols. And obviously, I'm not going to worship an idol. So I'm going to let them kill me. Why would God put me in that situation? Obviously, I sinned. So he was mourning because he couldn't find the sin. That's all he cared about. And Rabbi Akiva comes to him and he says, maybe one day, sometime in the past, you listened to the words of a heretic, an idol worshiper, and you were pleased with what you heard. Pleased! You enjoyed it. He told you, like "The Secret," if you think good, it will be good. Okay, a guy thought good; he got into a car accident. What about that guy? The secret didn't work for him. Or the guy that was the crackhead dealer who thought good because he thought he was going to be the next richest guy on the Forbes list got arrested and went to jail for 37 years. What about him? The Secret didn't work for him either? If you think good, it's going to work good? So, he says, maybe you heard something from some heretic. That's it, heard. Not like you started teaching it or wrote a book about it.

1:19:55brought a missionary, no, he heard it passing by. Obviously, this shows that even to hear, to overhear something that comes from heresy is not allowed. Something that comes from something impure is impure. So this very same holy kadosh, Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus, which I would not be allowed to say this if it wasn't written, says this: Akiva, you have reminded me. Once, I was walking in the upper market of Tzipori and I encountered one particular heretic from Christianity. And Yaakov of Kfar Sechania was his name. And he said to me, it's written in your Torah, "You shall not bring a harlot's hire." What is the law concerning making from a harlot's hire a lavatory for a Kohen Gadol?

1:21:18So this idol worshiper comes to him, and he says, "Listen, it's written in your Torah that you're not allowed to use any type of sheep that comes from a prostitute for anything holy. You're not allowed. It's a specific verse of the Torah. What about if you take her sheep, sell the sheep, and build him a new bathroom? Is there anything wrong with that?" She wants to give you as a korban. You don't use it for the korban; you don't make a whole celebration or anything. No, but since the Kohen Gadol, I mean, he's still human, even though he's as holy as it gets, he's still human, so he has to go to the bathroom. Since he's not going to go back home every time he has to go to the bathroom, they have a bathroom inside the Beit HaMikdash. So why don't you take the sheep, sell the sheep, and build him a new bathroom? Is there anything wrong with that?

1:22:20And I did not say anything to him in reply. I didn't respond to him. I didn't say anything. Can't talk to an idol worshiper. What am I going to do with this guy? I'm not going to start debating him Torah. He's saying it in the name of Yeshu. He's not saying it, oh yeah, I want to convert. So I didn't reply to him. However, Heretic then said to me, "My master has taught me this. As 'master' meaning J.C. Penny, my master has taught me this. Scripture states in the book of Micah, chapter 1, verse 7: 'For they were collected as harlot’s hire, and they will revert to harlot’s hire.' From which we derive, they came from a place of filth and..." and let them go to a place of filth. He says, listen, the whole argument behind using the sheep to go build a bathroom for the Kohen Gadol is that obviously her work is filth. So let that work pay for filth, for the bathroom. That was his logic. And Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus says this, and the heretic's dictum pleased me. His logic pleased me. It made sense.

1:23:51Her work is filthy, it's against Hashem. Whatever things she could produce in this world, I mean, it's obviously only filth. So let her stay with filth. Even her tzedakah will support filth. Logically, it made sense. But it's against the Torah. But he said just that type of insult. In essence, he's talking Torah. He's not talking about J.C. Penney, he's the Mashiach. Or he's a trinity, or anything like that. He's saying something that kind of makes sense. But it's against the Torah anyway. But the insult to the sinner pleased Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus to hear about this. Like, you know, it's funny. Let's say something like that. I therefore assumed that on account of this incident, I was seized for the purpose of being coerced into heresy. Just the fact that I enjoyed it for that moment, for that moment,

1:24:55made the heretic feel like I'm just like him, put us on the same playing field, and it was specifically because I transgressed that which was written in the Torah. zominut, distance yourself from her. This is referring to Proverbs 5:8: "Do not even come close, near the door of her house." This is a reference to the meaning of the heretics. Elaborate further on Proverbs and what he says in Proverbs chapter 5, verse 8. It says, "Distance your way from her, and do not come near the door of her house, lest you give your glory to others and your remaining years to the cruel one." The pshat here is to stay away from a promiscuous woman.

1:26:22Don't even come close to her door. Don't even put yourself to the test, lest all the goodness, all the shefa that Hashem is giving you, whether it's parnassah or anything good in this world, will go to others and your time will be spent with the cruel one, which he's talking about the Satan himself. You're going to be in Gehinnom and become BFFs with him. This is the pshat. But, if we look at some commentary, if you look at Tosefta in Masechet Chullin, Perek Bet Halacha 24. It says that this is specifically not just talking about the promiscuous woman, but it's also talking about the Minim. Minim means people that are causing other people to sin, whether it's causing other people to sin by becoming Mechalelei Shabbat, or causing other people to sin by having them do idol worship.

1:27:29And it's not just causing Jews to sin. Obviously, even more so if it's causing Jews to sin, but it's even if it's causing other non-Jews to sin. Bringing non-Jews to Christianity or Catholicism is a sin from the Torah. You're not allowed to do it. And Rabbi Eliezer ben Horkenos says, A person must always run away from something that is against Hashem in essence and something that even looks like it's against Hashem. From the missionary and from one that maybe means a missionary. Maybe. Maybe. Still not allowed to be next to him. Run. Run away. Not allowed to hang out with him. Not allowed to listen to his seminar. Not allowed to watch his videos.

1:28:36The Yad Ramah commentary on the same verse, also on Masechet Sanhedrin page 100b, on this very same talking commentary about Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus in a story that we just read in Avodah Zarah, says one is not allowed to learn anything from the Minim even if it doesn't contradict the Torah. Even if he's just talking to you about time management. Even if he's just talking to you about Shalom Bayit, be nice to your wife, raise your kids with good manners. Even that, you're not allowed to learn from him. As a side note, there's a very famous story about Rav Mordechai Eliyahu, who one time was asked to have a meeting with the Pope. And he said there's one condition: don't have crosses in the place that you want to meet me. I don't want to see any crosses. That's all. I'll meet you. I'll talk to you. Whatever you want to talk about. But make sure that wherever I go, there are no crosses. I'm not going to start bringing a Sefer Torah with me to show you. Don't show me your crosses. It's a fair deal. So,

1:30:08they went to a house and immediately they saw crosses. They were fooled into going into the house and they saw crosses. They ran out, got in the car, and left. This is an accident, it's not on purpose. He started praying to Hashem, "Hashem, if there's even a small punishment that will be given to me for walking into this house by accident, Please give me the punishment here in this world and not even a moment to suffer for it in the next world. As soon as he finished the prayer, the car rolled over the road and off the mountain on snow. He lived, but when everyone got out of the car, all banged up, they were all looking at each other, injured but laughing and happy. Laughing and happy, at least I suffered in this world for an accidental sin of walking into a house that had a cross on it. Needless to say, bringing the cross to our shul. Masechet Avodah Zarah, page 17a.

1:31:33says you're not even allowed to be within four amot—about six feet, seven feet—of a church, a place of idol worship, a Reform shul, or a Conservative shul. You're not even allowed to be within six feet of it. Forget about going in there; forget about bringing them to your shul. Needless to say... It's considered To'evat Hashem—disgusting to Hashem. I know many people watching online will be offended. Be offended. It's not my rules; it's God's rules. So now, what's the logical argument that the Ramchal is telling us they're going to use? Because they're blinded by foolishness and the Yetzer HaRa. what is the logic behind bringing him, still knowing that he's a missionary? Which I will prove later today—I don't know how much time I have, but we'll still have time to do it. There are two things: one, "Love your neighbor." Okay, if I love my neighbor, I don't want him to go to Gehinnom. So, as a matter of fact, not bringing him is loving my neighbor.

1:32:54Because if my neighbor has a teenage child that's typical of this disastrous generation that we have today, that has no idea why he's even alive, even if he has a kippah. If you haven't noticed, many teenagers are going off the derech. Many teenagers have no idea why anybody would want to be religious. It sounds like so much more fun not being religious. You can eat McDonald's, you can go to the Super Bowl, you can play baseball. You don't have so much homework. Sounds like fun. So many of them are going off the derech and smoking on Shabbat, and in the beginning, they're secular in secret. Shortly later, they become publicly secular, and they come out of the closet with their boyfriend sometimes. Sometimes it happens. So we have a weak generation. So if I bring this missionary that says, you know what? Don't do anything and you're perfect. Jesus loves you. What's the kid gonna do? I gotta call that guy. I gotta watch his YouTube videos. I gotta buy his book. I know Jesus. He knows him. I wanna talk to him. So yes, maybe he came to me and told me how to manage my time. Yes, I...

1:34:1617 years old, 16 years old, I don't really have much to manage. I'm sleeping most of the day, but maybe one day I'm gonna have to manage my time. But I kind of like what he said—that God loves me on his YouTube video. So what if his god is named something else? From what I've heard so far, his god sounds like so much more fun. Sounds like my kind of god. I want to go hang out with this god because he doesn't require anything. So, loving your neighbor means you're not going to be egotistical and arrogant enough to think that you know your neighbor is strong enough to withstand the slick tongue of the wicked. Psalm 12, verse 4: "May Hashem excise all lips of smooth talk."

1:35:20the tongue which speaks boastfully. Those who have said, "Because of our tongues we shall prevail; our lips are with us. Who is master over us?" Here, the Rambam, in his commentary on Pirkei Avot, also refers to this as Lashon Hara. So people... Saying, "Oh, maybe saying something about the Rabbi making a bad decision is Lashon Hara." But we already started this lecture by saying, in the place of this Chilul Hashem, there is no honor for the Rav. His blood is not any redder than yours. He made a bad decision. Every one of us is obligated to do whatever we can to undo it. Simple. It's nothing personal. He made a horrible decision. One of many. I've been there for two and a half years. I've just been quiet about all of them. And he's not the only one, unfortunately. The next argument is, if there's wisdom in the goyim, you should believe it.

1:36:45And the rest of the verse says, but if there's Torah in the goyim, don't believe it. If there's wisdom in the goyim, believe it. If there's no wisdom in the goyim, if there is Torah in the goyim, don't believe it. So don't learn Torah from them. but if they have other wisdom, they know about, I don't know, space travel, they know about time management, they know about motivational speaking, yeah, you should believe it. That's in essence what people think this means. It does mean that, but they forgot one small little tidbit. This does not include listening to goyim that are minim. This does not include the goyim that is an idol worshiper. You're not allowed to listen to him. even if he's Einstein times a thousand. Not allowed. One of the biggest reasons why you're not allowed is for the very same reason why Pinchas took it upon himself to go and take the spear and take

1:38:01another Jew's life. Rashi and also the Tosafot on Masechet Sanhedrin, page 82, explain that the rationale behind it was that if he wasn't going to do anything and let Zimri and Cozbi enjoy themselves. then this would have given a kosher sign on his action. It would have made it look okay. If we all say it's okay to bring the number one missionary in the world to go teach us something, whether it be time management or whatever other nonsense there is in this world to learn other than Torah, who's to say that six months from now, He's not going to be in every single synagogue on the East and West Coast teaching us about time management with a little bit of poison in between called Jesus. Because we okayed it. Dayan so-and-so okayed it. Why wouldn't a small little shul say, "Hey, listen..."

1:39:17Dayan so-and-so said it's okay. Posek so-and-so that we still don't know the name of said it's okay. Why couldn't we just learn about some of his other stuff? He even brought free books. I know, Jesus. He brought them for free. What a tzaddik. What a generous guy. Amazing story in a book called Ahavat Chaim. They talk about a story of the original Rabbi Pinto, Rabbi Chaim Pinto. A poor man in his kehillah one time found a coin. Now, he didn't know that this coin apparently had some kishuf in it, some type of wizardry of some kind. Connected to avodah zarah, it had the symbol of

1:40:19JCPenney on it, apparently. And as he's carrying the sack with the coin in it, this is almost a thousand years ago, by the way, it was 700 years ago. The story goes that he hears a voice from inside the sack, and he opens the sack and eventually discovers that this coin is talking. It says, if you take me out of the sack, you'll find a fortune today. Okay, interesting enough. Long story short, he takes the coin out of the sack, and next thing you know, he finds a big diamond. Shortly later, it tells him, "If you do this, I'll give you something else." And this continues on and on, and all of a sudden, this little poor guy becomes a gvir, becomes rich. One day he goes to Rabbi Pinto, Rabbi Pinto is obviously a big tzaddik, kadosh, who knows that nothing happens for no reason. So you ask him, where all of a sudden did you become very wealthy? What happened? I won't hide anything from you. I'll tell you, come. He takes him and shows him his palace, his house now.

1:41:41He shows him this fancy room, and the whole fancy room has only one little podium, and there's something in the middle, and he says, "What is it?" He sees this coin. He goes, "That's the reason. That's my segulah. That's my segulah." What's segulah? Coin is segulah? Where's the Torah that says coin is segulah? He goes, "No, no. This coin tells me what to do." So he looks closer into the coin, and he was a very holy man. He saw that there's kishuf. this coin and he started to take something and begin smashing it to destroy it. This is one hundred percent idol worship. We must destroy the coin, and you are not allowed to enjoy even one penny that you received as a result of this coin. Why? Because the Gemara Masechet Avodah Zarah says multiple times that you're not allowed to ever enjoy idol worship in any way, shape, or form. This is the reason why when Am Yisrael went into Eretz Yisrael, which was at that point still called Canaan, Hashem said, the first thing you have to do is destroy all of the Asherah trees. What did the poor trees do? They didn't protest. They weren't pro-Palestine.

1:42:55They didn't bring any missionaries. What do you want to destroy the trees for? What did they do? Someone bowed to them. Someone bowed to these Asherah trees at some point. Once, twice, five times, a thousand. It doesn't make a difference. If one time somebody bows to them, you must destroy them from the face of the earth. And you're not even allowed to use the wood to burn for fire to be warm. They must be destroyed from the face of the earth. The Rambam says it's a law: if an idol worshiper, a goy, writes a Sefer Torah, it's a mitzvah to burn it. A Sefer Torah costs 50, 60, 70 thousand dollars. So you got some guy to write it. What do you care what he believes?

1:43:55He wrote it. Wrote it nicer than a Jew, let's say. Let's say he did. Became an expert. Calligrapher. Spent a year doing it. Just like the Rabbi. Says the name of God. Not allowed to just tear up Hashem's name, chas v'shalom, burn it. It's a mitzvah. Mitzvah means a good deed. You go to Gan Eden for this. To burn this book. As a matter of fact, it also says it's a mitzvah to burn their books even if they're not connected to things that contradict the Torah. If they're idol worshippers, you have nothing to learn from them. The whole thing that we say means it's a mitzvah to blot out a rasha's name, someone that's against Hashem, someone that's an idol worshiper. It's a mitzvah to blot out their names, to completely erase them.

1:45:14Anyone that tells you, "Wow, you know what? This idol worshipper's book about some self-help, this idol worshipper's book about..." whatever book about intimacy, the idol worshipper's book about time management, this idol worshipper's book about, I don't know, Pikachu and the rest of his friends, it's really good. Said it's really good, that's it. He didn't say, listen, I bought it for you, I'm gonna bring him to the shul. He said it's really good, he gave it a compliment, that's it. Someone that gives an idol worshipper a compliment for his work, or anything he does, is violating one of the laws in the Shulchan Aruch, meaning, you're not even allowed to give it a compliment, unless someone would actually buy it and support idol worship. And Chas V'Shalom even start doing it themselves. Complimenting you're not allowed.

1:46:35To finalize this part, we've talked to many, many rabbis all over the world. Just locally, we have over 40 rabbis that are doing everything they can to stop this horrific chillul Hashem. Just locally. And when I say we, it's a group. Sometimes I've spoken to the big rabbis, sometimes others spoke to the big rabbis. So no one quote me, "Oh, you didn't speak," like they misquoted Rabbi Mizrachi. Saying, "Oh no, he said he spoke to Rabbi Kamenetzky." He didn't say that. As a matter of fact, if you look at the recording, he did not say that. He said someone spoke to him, someone from the group. After we started this whole balagan, others that are zealous for Hashem, love Hashem, and have an IQ above a monkey, joined us. Because they realized, chillul Hashem, you're not allowed to do this. So some make calls to this one, some may call to others. If I specifically made the call, I'll say I. I called the Av Beit Din of Jerusalem. Av, top, number one. Rav Gidon Ben Moshe. He almost started crying on the phone. And he said, if this happens, we have to put something like this on Keren. You wanna find out, call him. Tell him Yaron sent you.

1:48:07You'd like, I'll give you the phone number of the Av Beit Din in Yerushalayim. We also have letters to Rabbi Mazuz, who already wrote on his website to run away from this synagogue. Another rabbi wrote to him, saying not to go to this place. Rabbi Amnon Yitzchak ran away and actually said some bad things about the rabbi. Throw him out or something like that, I don't remember the words verbatim. We even have letters; I even actually spoke to the office of the Rishon LeTzion, the top rabbi in Israel. The office told me, "Of course this is not allowed. What kind of question is this? Is this a real question?" He asked me if I'm joking. He goes, "Wait, it's a Reform, right?" I said, "No, it's an Orthodox. Modern Orthodox." Modern Orthodox to us, it's like we already, like, we're so assimilated and misguided, we think it's the same. He said, "This is Orthodox? Of course, it's not allowed."

1:49:23What kind of question is this? He started lying. He was upset at me for asking such a question. A five-year-old boy in Yeshiva knows it's not allowed. We even have a letter I sent. I gave it. From two Dayanim. Two Av Beit Dins in America. In New York. Asking nicely, please cancel the event. It's not allowed. Not allowed. Ignored, as a matter of fact, after the letter was sent. The very next day, they lowered the price to zero dafka. Instead of hiding this event after finding out that they made a mistake, they make it easier for people to come, publicize even more, and make more flyers. I

1:50:26One of the big rabbis that I spoke to in Yerushalayim, when I told him, "Yes, but they're really worried about hatred from the goyim. Like most likely I'm going to get after this lecture. I'll probably get more hatred from wicked Jews than I am going to get from goyim. But nonetheless, it means nothing to me." So I told this rabbi, big, big mekubal. I told him, "They're worried about hatred from the goyim. You know, we are in America." He said this to me: Instead of being worried, tell the rabbi, the head rabbi, that instead of being worried that canceling the missionary event will cause hatred from the goyim, you should be really worried about your kehilla turning into goyim.

1:51:30In Pirkei Avot chapter 4, Mishnah 5, and it's also in Mesilat Yesharim, it talks about Chilul Hashem. When the Goyim see a Jew who looks religious, but he's a sinner, It's detested by Hashem more than anything else. More than even a secular Jew sinning. A secular Jew sins, a Goy sees him, he doesn't even know he's sinning; he thinks it's normal. Like, I remember when we first came to America, we had no idea about English, we had no idea about anything. Even the concept of things not even being kosher or not kosher was not really, you know, understood. We went to a diner and asked for a tuna sandwich in the limited English we knew. The guy gave me a tuna sandwich with this crackery thing on it. I'd never seen anything like it before. This brownish cracker thing on it, on a sandwich. I looked at it and I'm like, what is this?

1:52:52interesting, and I asked the guy, "What is it?" He says, "Oh yeah, it's good, it's good." "What is it?" "Oh, it's bacon, bacon." I said, "What's bacon?" Again, I only knew, personally, I only knew the alphabet or half the alphabet. My father knew a little English, and my brother knew a little English. The rest of us knew nothing. So my dad said, "Oh, it's bacon." I'm like, "What's bacon?" He's like, you know, bacon. I'm like, what? What's bacon? He goes, pig, pig. All of us knew pig. All of us practically got a heart attack. And he's like, why are you so surprised? Why are you so upset? I have many Jewish friends that eat bacon. So to him, he sees a secular Jew eating bacon. Eh, whatever. But when he sees the little Chassidic guy at the casino, or he sees the black and white bringing an idol worshiper, He thinks, ah, that's what they mean by the Torah. That's what they mean by righteous. They know better than us. That causes Chillul Hashem, my friends. And that's why Pirkei Avot says that anytime someone does Chillul Hashem, whether it's on purpose or by accident...

1:54:21In Shamayim, it's exactly the same. It's judged exactly the same. You made Chillul Hashem, desecrated Hashem's name by accident, or you did it intentionally. Same thing. Shows how disconnected you are from Hashem, whether it's on purpose or not. And for Chillul Hashem, for anyone who doesn't know and hasn't been taught about punishment... Part of the punishment is serious, serious suffering in this world, not just the next. In regards to the same verse that we talked about earlier in Proverbs 5:8, it says you're not even allowed to hang out with them, meaning you're not even allowed to be next to them. Even if you're confident in yourself not to fail, either because you're smart, tzaddik, dayan, chacham gadol, or you're just saying, listen, I know God's real. Leave me alone with this nonsense. Confident. It says you're not even allowed even for that. Because it's written in Proverbs 2:19, "All who come to her don't return."

1:55:51nor do they attain the paths of life. Chazal explains that those that go so close to idol worship eventually fall for it. Either they get weaker in their connection to Hashem or, chas v'shalom, become idol worshipers themselves. Like a dear friend of mine who is a rabbi, tzaddik... Tells me, "You have no idea how much we have to stop this." I said, "Yeah, I know we have to stop this." He goes, "No, no, you have no idea. I hate it more than you." I said, "You hate idol worship more than me? Maybe, but why? I mean, I know why I hate it, but why do you hate it?" He goes, "It's a rabbi. My father fell for a missionary. A rabbi's father fell for a missionary. To this day, he's idol worshiping." So he says those who come close to her, and we talked about before that her means the minim, the wicked idol worshippers, the heretics, don't return, nor do they attain their paths of life. And the paths of life, Chazal explain, means that they end up losing all of the shefa, all of the wealth, money, success, all the prizes that Hashem wants to give them.

1:57:16For the goodness they brought into this world, they gave some tzedakah, they gave some chesed, they did some kiruv. He wants to give them things. You listen to idol worshipers, He has to take it all back. And then people ask, why does the Holocaust happen? Why do we lose money? Why does the stock market crash and a lot of Jews lose money? Why does Bernie Madoff, yimach shemo, have to happen? Stop bringing missionaries. To finalize it all, for anyone who's still unsure, when this disaster first started, as you all know, this has nothing to do with my kavod, my wisdom, my nothing.

1:58:18If Moshe and Aharon said they're nothing, then I'm less than that. Not as a compliment, but as an insult. When I spent 16 years on Wall Street, my job was to find red flags. That was my job. My job was to find either a red flag that made an opportunity that everyone is missing, take advantage of it on the upside or a downside. Meaning, I either found that there is a possibility that something is worth a lot more money than what it's worth because everyone is missing something, for example, a forced merger or some type of acquisition or patent, anything like that, or I would look into the books and see that the company is cooking them. They're lying. They're lying about their numbers. The CEO is really a thief. He doesn't have a degree like he says he does. He's lying on his resume. Things like that. My job was to find red flags. That's what I do. My wife is even better at it than I am. As far as research is concerned, personally, I think she's the best there is.

1:59:41Nonetheless, when I saw this place, I noticed they were promoting someone, and the picture didn't exactly look Jewish to me or like a rabbi. I said, okay, interesting, who is this guy? And I'm very, very busy, so I said, I'll just count it as a reminder for myself to look into him at some point. just interested in who they think is appropriate for the rabbi because I ran into a different flyer that they had, and I obviously didn't attend any of these lectures. I saw that there were some other unwelcome guests at the shul a few months before, which I'll talk about momentarily. So I promised myself to actually look into it at some point. Anyway, eventually, I did. My wife did too.

2:00:43We just looked at our basic, just to see who this guy is, what kind of work he does, what kind of books he sells, what's his spiel. And also, I'm a speaker, so I appreciate other speakers. If he's a good speaker, I appreciate other speakers, whether they are monotone, charismatic, intelligent, and so on. I like to listen to other speakers, just for the sake of listening to their delivery, not necessarily the content, but rather the... Just to see how someone speaks. You know, you fluctuate your voice and so on and so forth. So, moments later, we started finding disaster after disaster. And this is how it started. January 23rd, 2017, at 3:10 a.m., I wrote an email to Rabbi Goldberg saying the following: Anyone that wants a copy of all this, I'd be more than happy to forward you all of them. I'm praying that this is simply a huge oversight that can still be stopped before it creates a huge destruction to our people and a desecration of the name of Hashem. After doing much further research, it's concluded with absolute certainty that this Matthew Kelly is one of the top missionaries for the Catholic Church in the world. To bring him here is not only dangerous but it's putting over 1,000 families at eternal risk. Here are some of the proofs. Included, I provided him with multiple links.

2:02:12And a snapshot picture of my proofs that this guy is not only a typical Christian, Catholic, nice or not nice guy, but rather proof that he's actually an active missionary. First thing is, I provided a three-minute video promoting his book. Three minutes of his book. If you can handle listening to the name Jesus a hundred times in a matter of three minutes, listen to this book. It's unbelievable. I've never heard anybody say the name so many times. Then we go into his website, his real company. It's called dynamiccatholic.com. Rediscover Jesus, another one of his books, another one of his topics, another big part of his mission. Then you look at the Wikipedia. I don't have a Wikipedia, but he does. Apparently, he's very, very successful, which is good for him, but unfortunately very bad for the rest of the world. Because you could even see in his Wikipedia, it says he sold more books about Christianity than any other book except the New Testament.

2:03:24If that doesn't make you sick enough, you just go to his personal site called matthewkelly.com, you look at upcoming events, and you see all of this. Now just in case, you say, nah, Catholics don't missionize, come on. Why are you so fanatic? Why are you so crazy? Why are you so accusing? Okay, so you just go to his website. Go to dynamiccatholic.com and you take a snapshot of one of the comments by Alan Wessen, W-E-S-S-E-N, from one month ago. So don't think it's old. One month ago. And he says the following: "Coming into the Catholic faith at 27 from the Jewish faith provides me with a slightly different view from the forest." I believe for most Catholics, being a good Catholic is simply head-focused—going through the motions or observing the performing and rituals we've learned growing up. I think this is awesome. Do I need to read more? Is this sickening yet? Is it missionizing yet? This was sent. And the end of the email says, "Hashem Yirachem."

2:04:45Same email I'm sending to Rabbi Goldberg, Hashem Yirachem, this is Sodom and Gomorrah and Churban Beit HaMikdash that's being brought to our holy Jewish people at the BRS community. Now, in case this is an accidental oversight, please do announce the cancellation of this event immediately. This was before anything went public. Before we put it on anywhere. The appropriate way to do things is to assume and give everyone the kaf zechut that they're making a mistake. The fact that he learned so much Torah in his life and became what they call a talmid chacham. you have to give honor. You have to give respect, and as a matter of fact, even if he was an ignoramus Jew, you still have to give him the benefit of the doubt, which I did. I didn't do what he did, actually, to Rav Mizrachi, which is, without even consulting with him, write a letter against him with 15 other rabbis. No, we don't do things like that. Number one, because it's against the Torah, and number two, it's just bad ethics. But nonetheless,

2:05:54We tried doing our best. We sent this letter. The response was sent the next day, thank Yaron. Thank you for your concern. Kelly speaks on religious issues, which we are obviously not bringing him for, and is a general motivational speaker as well. For example, his best-selling book, by the way, remember the sin I just told you about a few minutes ago? His best-selling book, and he gives me the link as if I'm gonna buy it, "Seven Levels of Intimacy" by Matthew Kelly, has nothing to do with religion. The end. I gave him sources that took me hours and hours to find, provide, copy, and paste. Honestly, the stress of this monster coming to our community should have at least warranted some more appropriate response. But this is what I got. No problem, he's a busy rabbi. I responded.

2:07:17I responded for more details. Nothing happened, so I sent another email on the 24th. I said, have you reviewed the material that I sent you and considered the fact that someone would stay in touch with them and thereby be led or misled to idol worship of the Catholic and Christian Church? Even if there is a 1% chance of that happening, are you really willing to take that chance? Let's say you have 1,000 families in the kehillah. This is several thousand people. Let's just say 500 to 1,000 show up to this lecture. Out of the 1,000 people, one guy, one little 15-year-old, little, you know, self-doubting Yid with a quarter-looking, you know, coat-keeper, likes the guy, thinks he's charismatic, says, "I'm gonna email him." Like they do to me a thousand times a day. Like they do to any speaker that has any charisma or perhaps speaks anything of sense. And sometimes no sense. They email you, they text you, they call you, they try to meet you, they come to your lectures. Let's just say a little quarter-keeper guy says, "I like this Matthew. Maybe he's a tzaddik nistar." It's a hidden tzaddik.

2:08:44And lo and behold, they connect, they befriend each other, and we lost a Jew. Are we willing to take that risk for one Jew? Forget the thousand, or ten thousand, or the fifty thousand that would be influenced by this. One. This was not responded to, so I sent another email. Rabbi Goldberg, I have not heard back from you and really hope that you're not taking this huge risk lightly. I am only trying to remind you of what you already know, but perhaps you've had a moment of forgetfulness due to your busy schedule. At this point, I still have respect for the guy. As a rabbi who speaks publicly, he speaks publicly at his shul and other places, they welcome him, and so on.

2:09:44As a rabbi who speaks publicly, you're very well aware that the connection with the crowd only begins at the lecture. As a professional speaker for over 15 years in business and then Torah, I have seen lectures lead to very long-term relationships that have been life-changing. If this lecture happens and the Jewish people of BRS and Boca Raton at large connect to him, this can lead to more assimilation and even conversion of Jews to Christianity, even though obviously it's not valid. Nonetheless, people think they become Christians. Some may think that I'm being a fanatic or extreme, but I have more experience in this field than anyone, as I was once part of the fallen. Before Hashem showed me His mercy by putting me through seven years of Gehenom that turned into Gan Eden, baruch Hashem.

2:10:44I beg you to please, please, please cancel this lecture immediately and remove the unbearable risk from our people. I look forward to hearing from you soon. Anyone who knows even a little bit about my story can understand what I mean. If everyone's been sleeping... at the wheel because their life has been just grand without any hardship, and they've never seen missionaries at work. They've never seen Jews attend church like my student who got tagged by a missionary over 40 years ago and just realized that Judaism is real after being married to a Goya for 45 years. Now he can't divorce her; he loves her, he's been with her for 45 years

2:11:45But she's not interested in converting. What's he going to do now? A nice missionary did us the favor. No. After he didn't reply to this email, I sent another one. I got an email from somebody else, who asked Rabbi Mutzafi, one of the Gedolei HaDor in Israel, and asked him his opinion about this. I told you his opinion was obviously according to the Torah: you're not allowed to listen to this person, you're not allowed to attend the synagogue, you're not allowed to do anything involved in this thing, or support it in any way.

2:12:45I'm not even allowed to comment on it in a positive way. So I showed him these writings from Rav Mutzafi, a much greater Rabbi than he is, a much greater Rabbi than I could ever be. One of the students of Rav Tzion Abba Shaul, the student of Rav Tzion Abba Shaul. And I showed him this. I said, Rabbi Goldberg, I just received this from another BRS member asking me what I think about the missionary that's coming to BRS because he saw this online. It looks like my concern is not just my own, as some other people from here had a similar concern by sending it to Rav Mutzafi, whom I only heard about but don't know. I don't know Rav Mutzafi personally; I just heard about him. I've seen a few of his videos, but I have no connection to him or anything. Have you considered my words in a previous email? Please advise regarding your decision about canceling the event, b'ezrat Hashem. So far, fair enough? At 2:14 p.m., I got the worst reply you could possibly get. Your own.

2:14:05We won't be canceling. I appreciate your concern, but he is coming as a motivational speaker and nothing more. That is clear to him, and that will be to the audience. Now, anyone that's read a little bit of Gemara knows that you're not even allowed to learn from a rabbi that has bad middot. I'm not talking about, obviously, not allowed to learn from an idol worshiper; we've just talked about this for two hours. But even if a rabbi has bad middot, you are not allowed to learn from him. So there's a story of Rabbi Meir Baal HaNes, one of the greatest sages that ever lived, one of the students of Rabbi Akiva. One of his other rabbis, Elisha ben Avuyah, went off the derech, went crazy. And he continued to learn from him. So a bunch of rabbis, you know, they say, what are you doing? You're not allowed to learn from somebody like that. He says, yes, I know how to decipher. I'm at a level I'm able to decipher the good and separate the nonsense from him. And still many went against Rabbi Meir Baal HaNes saying it's still a mistake. You're still not allowed. So apparently Rabbi Goldberg believes that his entire kehillah of a thousand people are bigger than Rabbi Meir Baal HaNes. None of them will be affected by this Matthew Kelly.

2:15:35So my last email was this: This is terrible news, and I'm sorry to hear that you clearly do not see the risk your decision is putting the entire community in. Due to these circumstances, I cannot allow myself or my family to be part of such a sin and an outright desecration of the name of Hashem, and I request to cancel our family's membership from the Boca Raton Synagogue effective immediately. In a place where there is Chillul Hashem, there is no consideration for the Kavod of the Rav. Masechet Sanhedrin, page 82a. The email was responded to a few hours later at 7:22 in the morning, and he copied his team, Matthew the... overseer of the synagogue, apparently the guy that organizes everything, Philip Moskowitz, the number two rabbi in the synagogue behind Ephraim Goldberg, David Shabtai, who is the rabbi for the Sephardic Kehilah, with one word, understood. The end.

2:16:55And that was it, my friends. I found out that I have no choice and I need help. We started praying, we started publicizing, we started doing everything we possibly can to make sure that the world at large, at the very least, if we could stop one person from attending this lecture, we would. But many people took this to heart. And are helping in every way they can. I even had one guy, Rav Zitron, a tzaddik from New York, who went to Israel, and he went to Rav Kanievsky. Rav Kanievsky, gadol hador. Okay, he doesn't get bigger. Rav Kanievsky right now, number one. He asked this question. Same type of response I got from the Rishon LeTzion. Obviously, they didn't write letters yet, which we're working on. Because no one wants to take the word that Rav Chaim Kanievsky is against Avodah Zarah, you know, Chas V'Shalom, you know. Or Rishon LeTzion. No one wants to take our word. Everyone thinks that we made this up. Like everything I just said for the last two and a half hours, I made it up. It's my own halachot. I became Moshe Rabbeinu. He asked the office of Rav Kanievsky, he said, what kind of joke is this? Of course, it's not allowed. You're not allowed to even have him in the synagogue, they said.

2:18:19inside the synagogue. As a guest, as anything. Not allowed. It's considered a sin. Now, if I told the kehillah everything I just said, many of them are going to bash me as much as possible. You are this and you are that, and you are this and you are that. But one thing I do know about this kehillah, some of them are very nice people, and some of them suffer still to this day because of the Holocaust. Families that died still cause suffering; even the survivors themselves sometimes suffer. There are still some Holocaust survivors among us. So if I told them that there was a certain speaker who was pro-Hitler, they would cancel the event immediately, right? Logically, I mean, you're a Jew. Even if you're not religious, if somebody says, "Listen, Hitler..." Decent guy. Anything positive about Hitler yimach shemo, it's not a good thing. Not for a Jew at least. Kavod Hashem? Not so much. Hitler? Okay, so let's just see. Let's just see some information from Matthew Kelly's work. Matthew Kelly.

2:19:49In his book, he writes this: "In preparing to write this book, I tried to take a fresh look at the Gospels and all the people in them. Excuse me for reading all of this garbage. I have to for the purpose of proving my point. I was hoping to rediscover Jesus by rediscovering the people he interacted with. The thing that fascinated me about the Pharisees..." As I rediscovered them, I saw that they always accused Jesus of blasphemy. By the way, Pharisees, for anyone who doesn't know, is a derogatory term for Jews. This was their big hang-up when it came to Jesus. To blaspheme is to speak of God in an irreverent, impious manner. In essence, he’s calling Jesus God. The paradox is that the Pharisees were, in fact, the ones blaspheming in the way they spoke to Jesus and about him. Now, in case you don't believe me that "Pharisees" means Jews, let's continue reading. There were others who even mocked Jesus. The soldiers mocked him, saying, "Hail, King of the Jews," and spat at him. Quotes Matthew 27:29. Can you imagine mocking God? Again, calling Jesus God.

2:21:14Okay, let's continue somewhere else. In case we didn't create enough anti-Semitism by the first part, let's create more anti-Semitism in part two. In his other book, he talks about It must have been an incredible experience because Paul would suffer tremendously for the rest of his life as a result of his belief in Jesus. The Jews tried to kill him because he publicly taught that Jesus was the son of God. Great, tell people about Jews doing bad things and come to our synagogue. Great job, buddy. Tell us more things that we did. This is again in another one of his books called Rediscover Jesus: An Invitation by Matthew Kelly, page 86. As a matter of fact, anyone who doesn't know, Paul was actually the one who caused the rise of Christian anti-Semitism. Next.

2:22:23In Rediscover Jesus, page 38, Matthew Kelly says this: God gave Moshe the Ten Commandments. By the time of Jesus, these had evolved to 613 mitzvot. In essence, he's saying we've changed the Torah. The simplicity of Jesus' teaching was radical, in contrast to the stifling effect these 613 laws have on our daily life. Oh yeah, I want this guy talking to my teenager and telling him the 613 commandments are stifling. Yes, great motivation. We're going to bring us back to the derech quickly this way. Okay, let's continue. Rediscover Jesus, page 47. What is he saying? Meaning he's talking about Jesus. What is Jesus saying? He's saying to love Emperor Nero, Adolf Hitler, Osama Bin Laden, and child molesters. And pray for them.

2:23:27I'm reading verse for verse. I didn't make this up. Even if I was crazy, I wouldn't make something like this up. This teaching is so radical that when we really stop to think about it, our chest gets tight. The airways to our lungs become constricted and we find it hard to breathe. Oh yeah, Jews at Boca Raton Synagogue and everywhere else that wants to accept Matthew Kelly, you need to love Adolf Hitler. Good job. You are a righteous Jew that way. Your grandparents will be so proud of you. Okay, next. Page 188 in Rediscover Catholicism. We move on to another book. Jesus Christ, born 2,000 years ago, Jesus of Nazareth, is not a myth or a legend, but a well-documented figure in history. But more than that, he is the Messiah. So now he's changed. He was God before, now he's back to being the Messiah. He switches. Switch, like you switch pants, he switches roles. He is the Messiah, who has been prophesied in the Jewish scripture, our Old Testament. Their New Testament, not ours. Our Old Testament, and long awaited by the Jewish people. Thank you for the insight. Originally, the event at BRS was called Passion and Purpose, led by Matthew Kelly.

2:25:00Matthew Kelly invites us all to identify God's voice in our lives and the specific purpose for which we've been created. This was on the flyer of Boca Raton Synagogue. No one found anything wrong with it, apparently. we're going to learn God's voice in our lives and the specific purpose. Why? Because it was pitched as if this guy is like some motivational speaker. I can't really say Tony Robbins because he's also an idol worshiper and he also mentions Jesus in his lectures. Just lay into them. If you go to, like, the seminars and you go deep into it, it starts talking about JC Penny. So whatever, this guy was pitched as like, you know, Motivational. This guy is going to be, I don't know, teaching you how to sell, teaching you how to live, teaching you how to be happy. I don't know what he's going to do. He's going to do something like this, but he's going to teach you about God too. Okay, so everyone got fooled into this. But interestingly enough, his phrase, "become the best version of yourself," wasn't originally that.

2:26:05Matthew explains the history of the phrase in his book, Four Signs of a Dynamic Catholic. In his earlier talks, he noticed that when he spoke about the Second Vatican Council's universal call to holiness, the eyes of his audience would glaze over. People weren't really that interested in that term. It wasn't marketable. Then one day, purely by accident, He instead used the phrase, "become the best version of yourself," and found that people started to become animated and engaged. So, he continued to use the expression in his talks and books. To become holy, to become a saint, is the same thing as to become the best version of yourself, to become all that God calls you to be. It's not pop psychology; it's just plain old Catholic teaching with a shift in language. As a matter of fact, he likes this "best version of yourself" so much that he trademarked it. And he also trademarked "universal call to holiness." And by the way, "universal call to holiness" means to him, Christ is the light of the nations. Hashem y'nachem.

2:27:29and as I told you before, he went to a campus to promote being a better you. And this is what they wrote briefly. According to Kelly, everyone, regardless of religion, must answer the question, who was Jesus? Mr. Kelly was asked what he thought about the problem of evil. He responded by saying suffering is part of the human experience. Christianity is the only religion that explains suffering. This is what he says, this idiot: Catholicism is your path to becoming the best version of yourself. This is again quoting people, not me. In case anyone thinks I'm exaggerating about his fees, you could just go to keynote speakers.com and put in his information. He used to charge $40,000 per lecture, plus demand a first-class ticket and so on. Now, I think it's $30,000. He got a little cheaper because he sells a lot of books, so he sells enough books to make up the other $10,000.

2:28:35Or, for whatever reason, it's $30,000. So apparently, someone, whether it's BRS or the Jewish Federation that's co-sponsoring this horrific Chillul Hashem, someone is paying a ton of money for us to be fooled by idol worshipping. Great. Now, is it convincing enough? Now, in case anyone says, okay, fine, this is a one-time error. Apparently, I myself was asleep at the wheel a few months ago. Because again, I generally, I'm very busy, I travel a lot, and I'm just not involved. Any synagogue that I go to, I go, I pray, I leave. I'm not involved. I'm not an involved person. I have my own thing that I do. So apparently I missed this thing where on the week of November 15th and November 25th, we had another AIPAC event. AIPAC is a big supporter of Israel, apparently, and many of the people in the congregation are members of it, and so on.

2:29:36Okay, great. Congratulations. Israel needs as much support as possible, as long as it doesn't go against God. Unfortunately, it is funded by many Christians and idol worshippers, and what ended up happening is that we invited some of them to the shul. So, on the week of Parashat Vayera, if you look at the weekly, which you can go on the brsonline.org website, and you can find the archives of the weeklies, you can see, actually, this was not the first time. As a matter of fact, on this weekend, we had a panel panel of Israel supporters that just happened to be Evangelical Christians, the number one missionaries on the planet, by the name of Oscar Bryan II, Stephen Marin, who calls himself a Christian Zionist Activist and advocate for Israel, William F. Callahan, and it was moderated by Ed Miller. One of them is actually a local financial advisor in Boca Raton. A very, very passionate Christian missionary. And they had a whole panel on Shabbat. On Shabbat. Kehillah. A thousand people showed up. I obviously didn't go, but I'm assuming at the very least 300 to 600 showed up, maybe more.

2:31:06panel. They had the floor to talk about how much they support Israel. The problem is no one sees through the lies and, excuse my language, their B.S. to see that yes, of course, they're supporting Israel; they're trying to convert all of you idiots. But all of us are comfortably numb, supporting this Chilul Hashem, and then we ask, "Hashem, why don't you give me parnassah? Hashem, why don't you give me a zivug? Hashem, why am I sick? Hashem, why does my wife not have any patience for me? Hashem, why is my husband so cheap?" Hashem this, Hashem that, Hashem this and Hashem that, and we constantly ask Hashem why He does this and why He does that, and where was He during the Holocaust, and where was He during the pogroms, and where were you when Chilul Hashem was about to happen? What did you do? You, sitting, watching, attending, what did you do?

2:32:33When Chilul Hashem was happening, I have a lot more material to make five other lectures. About personal people, about all types of other things that no one else knows, but we're going to leave it at this. Because again, this is not personal. This is about Kavod Hashem. Where is your Kavod Hashem? you're inviting idol worshipers and violating and desecrating the Torah. Where is it? How can you look in the mirror and say it's okay? Are you more confident than them? Do you think you're better than them? Do you think you could do better than them? Do you think you're more righteous than them? Or are you just comfortably numb, where you're enjoying this world so much? And instead of thinking about the Mashiach being around the corner and the world at large being a disaster, you don't really want the Mashiach to come. You just want to continue extending your kitchen, continue remodeling your house, and continue raising money for some other save-the-cat foundation. Where is your Kavod Hashem?

2:33:52I don't care if you're a rabbi, you're a dayan, you're a small rabbi, a big rabbi. None of that stuff matters to me. The only thing that should matter to any of you is Kavod Hashem. Now, this is part one of the lecture. If it has to, it'll get worse. If it has to, it will get worse. Because in a place that there's Kavod Hashem, there's no consideration for Kavod HaRav. Yes? Let's keep it, I told you before. Let's keep it off. I understand. Let's keep it. Anyone that wants to find out more information can find out on their own. This is purely halacha. This is purely Torah. So that way they can't say, "Oh no, it's a personal battle between Rabbi Mizrahi and Ephraim Goldberg, or Yaron Reuven and Ephraim Goldberg." It has nothing to do with it. Aside from the fact that he made a disaster of a Chilul Hashem by signing that letter against Rabbi Mizrahi, aside from the fact that he blamed Rabbi Mizrahi before Rabbi Mizrahi even knew about this. Before Rabbi Mizrahi even knew that this was all happening, he was already blamed for doing this campaign of going against this whole thing.

2:35:15And on top of it, he writes, "Listen, Rabbi Mizrahi had a debate against a Christian professor several years ago. What's so different about me bringing Matthew Kelly?" He's comparing Rabbi Mizrahi destroying Christianity, which has caused many Jews to do teshuva, many non-Jews to convert to Judaism or at the very least leave Christianity. One of them is in the crowd. I just met him today. saw the debate for the first time and he says, "Obviously, I know that Christianity is nonsense." He left it, and now he's in the process of converting. He's right here; watch the debate. I didn't plan this; I never knew him before today. Apparently, he's been watching my lectures for a long time. So he's comparing Rabbi Mizrachi doing a huge Kiddush Hashem that no one's willing to do really, except maybe a couple of other rabbis, like Rabbi Tovia Singer, Rabbi Skobac, but the way Rabbi Mizrachi did it, he destroyed it. Better than anyone else in my opinion. He's comparing that, fulfilling the mitzvah of abusing idol worship, insulting it, destroying it, that Kiddush Hashem, that mitzvah, he's comparing it to bringing a great white evil shark

2:36:34to a bunch of little sardines, that have no idea the shark is there. What is this like? It's like somebody saying, listen, I'm a tzaddik, I'm a tzaddik, I'm gonna bring more fish into the tank. And he keeps bringing more fish into the tank, and he brings more fish into the tank. He's like, look, I'm feeding them, and I'm feeding them, and they have divrei Torah, and they have lectures, and they have Daf Yomi, and they have this, and we have a synagogue, and it's a fancy synagogue, and we have a Holocaust center next to it, and everything is great, and wow, and then next thing you know, after he fed them, and everybody got really fat, and comfortable, and lazy, and comfortably numb, what does he do? He brings the great white shark. It was better off, you didn't build the community, just don't bring the great white shark. Where's the Kvod Hashem? Where is it? What god do you believe in that you think it's okay to bring an idol worshiper? Where does it say it? Where? Show me the halakha. Show me one real posek. Name the guy. Name the posek. Name two poskim that said. You said two poskim said. Well, I found out one of them. And he said it's only b'diavad because you already made a mistake that maybe you allow it. But the reality of it is he doesn't know the size of the mistake. Because according to the article that was written as a rebuttal for everything that we're doing, even the article misquoted everything.

2:37:54I know how to write also. I wrote some things in my life. I know the power of speech. I know how you can twist words. I fought the government. I fought major multi-billion dollar companies. I fought individuals. I fought everyone. For the first time in my life, I know for sure I'm right. Because G-d said so. Where is your kavod Hashem that you're bringing an idol worshiper to teach a bunch of... Clueless Jews that are just sleeping at the wheel, scared to even respond. Yeah, I know. I'm just not gonna go. I know you're right on your own. I know you're right. You're a great person, Rabbi, but I'm just not gonna go. Okay, but why can't you speak out? Yeah, but I know I'm gonna cause problems for my kids. They have to move, change yeshivas. People are gonna look at me funny. You know, I don't want to cause any problem. I already bought the house. You know, we just expanded the house. We just redid the kitchen. We have a bar mitzvah coming up in two months. Everyone is so comfortably numb. They don't want to destroy their lives and disturb them. But asking Hashem for a bigger house, another house, more kids, a cure for cancer...

2:39:21They ask, like one of the rabbis, Moskowitz, asked for. Not too long ago, a year and a half ago or so, he had cancer. Hashem gave him a cure. You can't say thank you by kicking this guy out. Say, "Matityahu, thank you," by no thank you. When Goldberg and family got all their kids, Baruch Hashem, they told us a story of an unfortunate experience. They had a pregnancy. But when He gave them more kids and you cried on stage and told us, you can't give them a little bit of thank you back? So what if you spent money? So what if your honor is destroyed? So what if you look stupid? Better to live a lifetime of stupidity in this world than one minute of being a shaygetz in Hashem's world. One minute. Where is your Kavod Hashem? What God do you believe in? Everyone can see that it's not fake news. The point has already been made. The point has already been made. Everyone knows the facts. Anyone who wants this information can email me.

2:40:43I'd be more than happy to send it to you. You can look it up online yourself in case you don't trust my sources. You want to look it up. I provided the websites. Call Matthew Kelly yourself. Watch his videos if you can handle it. In reality, you're not allowed to. You're not allowed to. But for the purpose of destroying this whole thing and hoping it doesn't happen, we had to. We used even non-Jews for help as much as we can so we don't have to be tainted by this Chillul Hashem. Please, cancel the event. Baruch Adonai le'olam. Amen ve'amen. tainted by this Chillul Hashem. Please, cancel the event. Baruch Adonai le'olam. Amen v'amen.

BH Headquarters